| Past Senior Player of the Year Award Winners | |
| 2025 | Tracy Phillips |
| 2024 | Tracy Phillips |
| 2023 | Brent Wilcoxen |
| 2022 | Jim Young |
| 2021 | Tim Fleming |
| 2020 | Tim Fleming |
| 2019 | Tim Graves |
| 2018 | Tim Fleming |
| 2017 | Mark Fuller |
| 2016 | Jim Kane |
| 2015 | Tracy Phillips |
| 2014 | Tracy Phillips |
| 2013 | Rod Nuckolls |
| 2012 | Jim Kane |
| 2011 | Michael Gowens |